Welcome back to our "New Year, New Customers" series on beating the January sales slump.
In Part 1, we covered the psychology of January shoppers and how to capitalize on New Year's resolution buying. Now let's talk about something equally important: the customers you already have.
You just spent December acquiring a bunch of new customers. Some bought for themselves; many bought gifts for others. Either way, you have a list of people who've already trusted you with their credit card.
That's valuable. But it's also perishable.
Customer attention fades fast. If you don't re-engage those holiday buyers in January, they'll forget you by February—and you'll have wasted all that December acquisition spend.
Let's make sure that doesn't happen.
The Post-Holiday Thank You (That's Actually Useful)
Skip the generic "Thanks for your order!" email. Everyone sends those, and they get ignored.
Instead, send something genuinely valuable:
For gift-givers: "Hope your gift was a hit! If your recipient needs a different size or has questions, we're here. And if YOU want to treat yourself now that the holidays are over, here's 15% off your next order."
For self-purchasers: "How's that [product] working out? Here are some tips to get the most out of it..." (Then include actually helpful content, not just upsells.)
The goal is to feel like a follow-up from a friend, not a transaction receipt from a corporation.
The "Didn't Buy?" Follow-Up
What about everyone who browsed but didn't purchase during the holidays? They were interested enough to visit—maybe they were comparison shopping, maybe they got distracted, maybe shipping deadlines scared them off.
January is your second chance.
Email angles that work:
- "Still thinking about it? Good news—no more shipping deadlines to stress about."
- "That [product] you were eyeing is still here. And now it's 20% off."
- "Holidays are over. Time to treat yourself."
Don't forget: Cart abandonment sequences should absolutely be running in January, not paused. If anything, conversion rates on abandoned carts often improve in January because the urgency pressure is gone and people can make calmer decisions.
Turn Gift Recipients Into Customers
This is huge and often overlooked.
Someone received your product as a gift. They didn't choose you—someone else did. But now they've experienced your product, and if it's good, they're a warm lead.
The problem: You don't have their email address. The gift-giver does.
Solutions:
1. Include a card in every order with a QR code or URL: "Love this? Sign up for 15% off your next purchase." Direct them to a dedicated landing page for gift recipients.
2. Make returns and exchanges easy and use that touchpoint to capture their info. Even a size exchange is an opportunity to turn a gift recipient into a subscriber.
3. Run social campaigns in January targeting people who might have received your products: "Got [your product] as a gift? Here's how to get the most out of it..." Educational content works great here—tutorials, styling guides, usage tips.
4. Encourage gift-givers to share. In your post-purchase emails to the original buyer, include easy forwarding: "Want to share care instructions with your gift recipient? Forward this email!"
Loyalty Program Push
If you have a loyalty or rewards program, January is the perfect time to promote it.
People are thinking about being smarter with money (hello, credit card bills), and "earn rewards on purchases you're already making" fits that mindset perfectly.
If you already have a loyalty program:
- Send a dedicated email reminding customers of their points balance
- Highlight any expiring rewards to create urgency
- Promote double-points events for January purchases
If you don't have a loyalty program:
January is actually a great time to launch one. You have a fresh list of holiday customers to invite, and the "new year, fresh start" energy works for your brand too.
Shopify apps like Smile.io, LoyaltyLion, or Yotpo make setup pretty straightforward. Even a simple "earn points, get discounts" structure can meaningfully improve repeat purchase rates.
Segment and Personalize (Even Simply)
Not all holiday customers are the same. Even basic segmentation makes your re-engagement more effective:
First-time buyers vs. returning customers First-timers need nurturing and education. Returning customers need appreciation and exclusivity.
High spenders vs. discount buyers Someone who bought at full price has different expectations than someone who only converted during your 40% off sale.
Product category purchasers If you sell across categories, someone who bought fitness gear probably doesn't want emails about your craft supplies (and vice versa).
You don't need a fancy CDP to do this. Even basic Shopify customer tags or Klaviyo segments can power more relevant follow-ups than blasting your entire list with the same message.
Key Takeaways: Re-Engaging Holiday Customers
Here's what to remember:
-
Your holiday customer list is valuable but perishable. Act in January or lose them by February.
-
Make follow-ups useful, not just promotional. Tips, education, and genuine helpfulness build relationships that lead to repeat purchases.
-
Don't forget the browsers who didn't buy. January removes the shipping deadline pressure—they might be ready now.
-
Gift recipients are hidden customers. Create pathways to capture their info and convert them from "received a gift" to "chose your brand."
-
Loyalty programs shine in January when people are thinking about smarter spending.
Up Next: What Actually Sells in January?
Okay, so you're reaching resolution shoppers and re-engaging holiday customers. But what should you actually be promoting?
In Part 3, we break down the product categories that consistently perform in January—and more importantly, how to position your products to fit the January buying mindset, even if you're not selling gym equipment or planners.